Months after Hurricanes Lala and Lowell, some Hawaii homeowners and small businesses are getting claim denials, and federal aid for individuals has been turned down. A denial is not always the final answer. Here is how to read it, what state regulators expect from insurers, and the steps you can take.
What happened
This week, KHON2 reported on a Kaʻū restaurant owner who carried hurricane coverage but says his claim was denied after an appraisal, even though a storage garage and its contents were destroyed. The dispute appears to turn on a common issue in storm claims: whether the damage was caused by wind, which a hurricane policy may cover, or by water, which may be excluded or covered only by a separate flood policy.
Earlier this month, Big Island Now reported that FEMA declined individual assistance for residents of Hawaiʻi and Kauaʻi counties affected by the storms. Hawaiʻi County plans to appeal and is asking residents whether their insurance claims were denied and why. With federal help uncertain, private insurance is the main source of recovery for many families.
State regulators have weighed in. In August, the Insurance Commissioner issued Memorandum 2026-7A telling property insurers how they are expected to handle Lala claims.
What it means for you
The Commissioner's memo sets out several points that matter if your claim was denied or underpaid:
Each claim stands on its own facts. Insurers are expected to look at the actual cause, location, and timing of the damage, rather than labeling all damage from a storm the same way.
A storm's name or a weather warning is not the deciding factor. According to the memo, a hurricane watch or warning, or the fact that a storm was named, does not by itself determine which coverage or deductible applies. The policy language does.
Denials must be explained. If an insurer denies or limits a claim, or applies a particular deductible, it is expected to point to the specific policy provisions and explain both the facts and the contract terms behind its decision.
You should not be caught between policies. Homeowners, hurricane, flood, renters, and condo policies cover different things. The memo says policyholders should not be pushed into disputes between insurers or discouraged from filing because another policy might ultimately apply.
Hawaii law also prohibits unfair claim settlement practices under the Insurance Code, HRS § 431:13-103, and Hawaii courts have recognized that an insurer can be liable for handling a claim in bad faith. Whether you have a claim beyond the policy benefits depends on the facts, so a denial alone does not mean the insurer acted improperly.
Practical steps
Get the denial in writing and read it closely. Ask for a written explanation that identifies the exact policy language the insurer relied on. If the letter is vague, ask for clarification in writing.
Request a complete copy of your policy. Include all endorsements and the declarations page. Hurricane deductibles, wind and water exclusions, and "anti-concurrent causation" language are often found in endorsements.
Compare the reason to the facts. If the insurer says the damage was caused by water but you believe wind damaged the roof first and let the rain in, gather evidence that shows the sequence of events.
Build your own record. Keep photos and video, repair estimates, receipts, contents lists, and a log of every call and email with dates and names. Save damaged items, or photograph them before disposal, if you can.
Consider an independent opinion. A licensed contractor, engineer, or licensed public adjuster may be able to assess the cause and scope of damage. Confirm any adjuster's license and understand their fee before signing.
Understand the appraisal clause. Many property policies allow either side to demand appraisal when you disagree about the amount of a loss. Appraisal usually decides value, not whether something is covered, and it can affect your other options, so review it carefully before invoking it.
Ask for reconsideration. Send a written appeal with your new evidence and ask the insurer to respond by a specific date.
Contact the Insurance Division. The Hawaii Insurance Division accepts consumer complaints and says it will monitor Lala claim complaints. Its number is 1-844-808-3222, and complaint information is available on its consumer resources page.
Tell your county. If you were affected and your claim was denied, Hawaiʻi County has asked residents to share that information to support its FEMA appeal.
Watch the deadlines. Policies often set time limits for proof of loss, appraisal demands, and lawsuits, and those limits may be shorter than you expect. Talk to an attorney before a deadline passes.
We can help you review your options
If your hurricane, homeowners, condo, or business property claim was denied or underpaid, our office can review your policy and the insurer's decision and explain your options under Hawaii law. Contact us to schedule a consultation.
This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a licensed Hawaii attorney.