A new report about a Kāneʻohe homeowner who says she paid roughly $30,000 in cash for a yard and pool project that was never completed is a timely reminder: before you hand over a deposit, confirm your contractor is licensed. Below is a summary of relevant Hawai’i law and tips on how to protect yourself.
On November 17, Honolulu Civil Beat reported on a Kāneʻohe teacher who says she paid an unlicensed contractor about $30,000 in cash for landscaping and pool work that was left unfinished. She has sued, alleging breach of contract, deceptive business practices, and unjust enrichment. These are allegations, and the case has not been decided.
According to the report, court records show a long history of civil claims and default judgments involving the same individual, and the Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs (DCCA) had previously obtained a fine against him for contracting without a license. The article also noted that DCCA has issued relatively few fines for unlicensed pool work in recent years, which means enforcement alone cannot be counted on to protect homeowners.
This story lands at a time when many households are planning repairs and is all too familiar to Hawai’i homeowners. After recent Kona low storms, the Hawaii Insurance Division issued a declaration relating to Hurricanes Lala and Lowell, and repair work tends to attract both legitimate businesses and people looking for quick cash.
What it means for you
In Hawaii, most construction work requires a contractor's license under HRS chapter 444. A license is generally required once a project's total value exceeds $1,500. Specialty work, such as roofs, plumbing, electrical work, may require a particular license classification, so a general "handyman" is not always allowed to do the job.
Hiring someone without a license puts you at a real disadvantage if you run into a conflict with the contractor:
Cash is hard to trace. Paying in cash leaves little record of what you paid, when, and for what without documented receipts and a contract detailing the specific scope of work.
Collecting a judgment can be difficult. Even if you win in court, a contractor without a license is likely without insurance or sufficient assets to collect on any judgment.
You still may have legal options. Hawaii's consumer protection law, HRS chapter 480, prohibits unfair or deceptive acts in trade, and in some cases consumers who are harmed may seek treble damages and attorney's fees. Whether a claim makes sense depends on the facts, the contract, and whether the contractor has assets.
Practical steps
Before you hire:
Check the license. Search the contractor's name and license number on DCCA's Professional and Vocational Licensing search. Make sure the license is current and covers the specific type of work you need. DCCA publishes a guide to license classifications.
Check the business and its history. Look up the company on the Hawaii Business Express registry, and search DCCA's complaint history and judgments list.
Confirm who you are dealing with. If someone says they work for a licensed company, call the company directly and make sure the Responsible Managing Employee (RME) listed on its license executes the contract.
Get a written contract. It should describe the scope of work, materials, price, payment schedule, and start and finish dates. Hawaii law requires certain disclosures in home improvement contracts, so a contractor who refuses to put anything in writing is a significant red flag.
Keep deposits modest and pay by traceable methods. Use a check or credit card, tie payments to completed milestones, and get a receipt every time. Do not issue a final payment until the agreed upon work is complete.
If a job stalls or conflict arises with the contractor:
Document everything. Save texts, emails, receipts, photos of the work, and notes of conversations with dates.
Put your concerns in writing. Send a clear, dated message describing what is incomplete and asking for a response by a specific date.
File a complaint. You can report unlicensed activity and contractor problems to DCCA's Regulated Industries Complaints Office, and you can file a consumer complaint with the Office of Consumer Protection.
Talk to an attorney about deadlines. Claims have time limits, and small claims court, a civil lawsuit, or a recovery fund claim may each be an option depending on the amount and the contractor's license status.
We can help you review your options
If you paid a contractor for work that was never finished, or you are unsure whether a contract protects you, our office can review your situation and explain your options under Hawaii law. Please contact us using the link in the header to schedule a free initial consultation.
This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a licensed Hawaii attorney.